Catch study: what actually drops, and how often
Every catch below comes from an in-game chat log, parsed line by line. Each figure is a share of catches, meaning casts that brought something up, whether fish or junk. Missed casts ("You have failed to catch anything") are left out because they come from the player's reel-in timing, not from the drop table. Rates are shown with 95% confidence intervals (Wilson score). With small samples these intervals are wide, so treat single-digit counts as rough.
Data is grouped by area and proficiency band (1–50, 51–100, 101–150, 151–200, the same bands as the "Where to fish" guide) and never mixed across them. What the water yields depends on both, so mixing them would blur the rates.
Study groups
What you catch, by category
"Cooking fish" are standard fish used in Cook recipes (Dace and Catfish at this level range). "Trophy fish" are the rare named variants (e.g. Delightful Dace) that the taxidermist in Bree exchanges for wall trophies.
Drop rate per item (% of catches, with 95% interval)
Show as table
Proficiency progression
Observed vs. documented levels
Sessions in this study
Getting started
Fishing arrived with Book 13: Doom of the Last-king (April 2008). It was LOTRO's only hobby until Birding was added in Update 41. To learn it, talk to a Hobby Master. They teach the skill, give you a Basic Fishing Rod, and send you on a short quest to the local Fishing Supplier. Then find any body of water and cast. There are no skill requirements to fish anywhere, but some fish only live in certain regions.
Put the Fishing skill on a quickslot. Press it to cast, wait for the bobber to dip and your rod to bend, then press it again to reel in. Combat interrupts fishing.
Hobby Masters (fishing trainers)
| NPC | Region | Location | Map |
|---|---|---|---|
| Henry Oakeshott | Bree-land | Scholar's Stair Archives, Bree | 30.5S, 51.7W |
| Refkell | Ered Luin | Hall of Kings, Thorin's Hall | 13.8S, 103.2W |
| Estmar Bolger | The Shire | The Bird and Baby Inn, Michel Delving | 33.4S, 75.4W |
| Brago Puddifoot | The Shire | Bywater Pool | 31.2S, 70.0W |
| Misty Bolger | The Yondershire | Gamwich | 23.7S, 82.4W |
| Hobby Master | Swanfleet | Lhan Garan | 54.9S, 27.7W |
| Hobby Master | North Downs | Trestlebridge Gate (West) | 17.7S, 54.5W |
| Hobby Master | Wildwood | Linnet's Camp | 22.0S, 57.7W |
| Hobby Master | Evendim | Trader's Wharf | 21.4S, 61.5W |
| Haldúr | Trollshaws | Hall of Fire, Last Homely House (Rivendell) | 29.8S, 3.4W |
| Arnfin | Moria | The Twenty-first Hall | 5.7S, 105.2W |
| Hobby Master | Dunland | Galtrev / Lhan Rhos / Durgors | 79.9S 16.9W · 87.2S 23.2W · 88.1S 25.8W |
| Hobby Master | East Rohan | Snowbourn, Sutcrofts | 61.1S, 61.3W |
| Hobby Master | Wildermore | Forlaw | 38.9S, 61.1W |
| Hobby Master | West Rohan | Aldburg, Eastfold | 69.4S, 64.5W |
| Dúdrad (fishing only) | West Rohan | Edoras, Kingstead | 62.7S, 74.7W |
| Hobby Master | Western Gondor | Dol Amroth, Havens of Belfalas | 75.1S, 70.3W |
| Hobby Master | King's Gondor | Harlond, Lossarnach | 72.8S, 18.9W |
Useful NPCs
- Fishing Suppliers sell replacement Basic Fishing Rods if you lose or sell yours. Examples: Joy Bloomer by Little Staddlemere in Staddle, Bree-land (31.2S, 49.4W), and Nokki south of Noglond, Ered Luin (19.7S, 100.4W). NPCs titled "Fisherman" or "Guide" also sell rods.
- Elmo Whitbread, the fishing taxidermist at Whitethorn's Taxidermy in Bree, trades trophy fish for mounted wall trophies for your house.
- Rûsu in Sûri-kylä (Forochel) sells the Flounder cooking recipes (needs Lossoth of Forochel standing).
Proficiency and the daily cap
- Proficiency runs from 0 to 200. Check it under Character → Hobby by hovering over the bar under the hobby description.
- Only fish raise proficiency. Junk never does.
- Each fish has a "trivial" level. Once your proficiency passes it, that fish stops raising your proficiency, so you need higher-level fish (and eventually higher-level water) to keep advancing.
- You can gain about 10 levels per day. When you hit the cap the hobby bar turns yellow (blue means you can still gain). There is no chat message when the cap is reached, only when you level. You can keep fishing, but you won't gain more until the cap resets at 2:00 a.m. server time. At 10 per day, 200 takes at least 20 days.
- Rule of thumb: if you land 6 or more fish in a row without a level-up, you have hit the daily cap, or the water is too high or too low for your level.
- Past 150 it slows down. You can still gain 10 per day, but each level takes more than 6 casts.
Fishing rods
A better rod gives an invisible bonus to your fishing skill, which shifts what you can catch. It does not raise your proficiency itself.
| Rod | Bonus | How to get it |
|---|---|---|
| Basic Fishing Rod | none | Gift from the Hobby Master; sold by Fishing Suppliers |
| Yew Fishing Rod | +1 | Woodworker craft |
| Well-crafted Yew Fishing Rod | +3 | Critical success on the Yew rod (Bind on Equip) |
| Lebethron Fishing Rod | +4 | Woodworker craft, Artisan (Tier 4) |
| Well-crafted Lebethron Fishing Rod | +5 | Critical success on the Lebethron rod |
| Rohirric Fishing Rod | +8 | Barter: Eastemnet Miscellany Quartermaster |
| Exquisite Elven Fishing Rod | +10 | 45 Tokens of the Lake and Rivers from the Erebor, Felegoth or Dale reward Quartermasters |
Racial bonus: the River Hobbit earned trait River-folk adds an invisible +25 to fishing skill. Bait (Leech, Nightcrawler, Red Wiggler) existed when fishing launched but is no longer part of the system.
Where to fish at each proficiency level
To keep gaining proficiency, the water has to match your level. If it's too low, the fish there are trivial and stop raising proficiency. If it's too high, you catch more junk. The regions below are the community-recommended bands. Inside each band, any lake or river works. Your rod and race add to your effective skill, so a better rod lets you move to the next band a little sooner.
Handy spots
- Your own homestead (any player-housing neighbourhood) has fishable water that gives proficiency up to about 95. It's the most convenient place to level through the first half. Tested: in the Ered Luin homesteads a character went from 11 to 21 in 17 catches.
- Cooking fish: the coast of Echad Sirion (Mirkwood), Lake Evendim and Sûri-kylä (Forochel) are recommended for edible fish.
- Long Lake (Lake-town, Dale-lands) has its own species for the Lake-master deed.
- Tested by us: Halecatch Lake near Andrath, just south of Bree (proficiency 1–45), and the Ered Luin homesteads (11–21). See the catch study for exact drop rates there.
Observed fish by level (our data only)
This table comes only from the chat logs in our study. Nothing in it is taken from wikis or older guides. "Lowest proficiency seen" is the lowest level at which we've actually caught the item. "Effective skill" adds the rod bonus recorded for that session. Where we haven't logged a level range yet, an item can't show up there, so this table only reflects levels we've actually fished. It grows as we add sessions.
Standard fish by level (community guides)
"Available" is the proficiency at which a fish starts appearing. "Raises proficiency through" is its trivial level. These figures come from the community Angler's Guide, compiled when fishing launched. Later updates appear to have shifted some of them; see "Observed vs. documented" in the study above.
| Fish | Available at | Raises proficiency through | Trophy variant | Uses |
|---|
Trophy fish
Each standard fish has a rare named variant, such as Giant Goldfish, Delightful Dace or Big Mouth Bass. They are Bind on Acquire barter items. Take them to Elmo Whitbread at Whitethorn's Taxidermy in Bree and he exchanges each one for a small wall trophy for your house. Trophy fish aren't worth much at a vendor. Their trophy variants are listed in the table above.
Junk
Junk sells for a few coppers and never raises proficiency. Higher-level junk appears as your proficiency rises.
| Item | Appears from about |
|---|---|
| Weeds | 1 |
| Rusty Dagger | 5 |
| Ball of Gunk | 10 |
| Rusty Hammer | 50 |
| Old Boot | 65 |
| Rusty Mace | 85–90 |
| Drift-wood | 105–110 |
| Rusty Sword | 125 |
| Dirty Skull | 145–149 |
| Rusty Axe | 165–172 |
| Broken Barrel, Old Glove, Rusty Tankard | higher levels |
Rare fish and fishing deeds
Some species have nine variants that depend on both proficiency and region. Only fish you catch yourself count toward a deed. Buying or trading them doesn't. Each group deed rewards a title and a group trophy.
Trout-master
All nine trout can be caught in the North Downs, Trollshaws, Evendim, Lone-lands and the Dale-lands at proficiency 50+, at the same rate in any water there.
Brown 60 · Redband 70 · Cutthroat 75 · Bull 80 · Red-spotted 80 · Speckled 85 · Rainbow 90 · Golden 90 · Lake 95
Darter-master
All nine darters can be caught in Angmar, the Misty Mountains and Forochel at proficiency 100+, at the same rate in any water there.
Redfin 60 · Orangefin 70 · Greenfin 73 · Bandfin 75 · Longfin 80 · Blackfin 85 · Bloodfin 87 · Firebelly 90 · Splendid 100
Sturgeon-master
Catch all nine sturgeon. Original regions: Bree-land, Ered Luin and the Shire (Dwarf, Shovelnose); Lone-lands and North Downs (Shortnose); Evendim and Trollshaws (Green, Pallid, Lake, White); Angmar, Forochel and Misty Mountains (Fringebarbel, Starry). Later expansions added more regions (e.g. Dwarf Sturgeon in East Rohan and Enedwaith; White Sturgeon in the Entwade near Snowbourn).
Dwarf 60 · Shortnose 69 · Fringebarbel 70 · Green 75 · Pallid 75 · Shovelnose 80 · Lake 88 · Starry 90 · White 100
The Salmon King
Catch a 50-pound Salmon. It grants the title The Compleat Angler, and the fish can be mounted by the taxidermist. Reported from the Lone-lands, Mirkwood, Misty Mountains, Rivendell, Enedwaith, East and West Rohan and Dunland, among others. Players report needing very high proficiency (151, and some say 200).
Smaller salmon (2 to 40 lb) appear from proficiency 10 to 100 in various regions.
Lake-master
Catch twenty Long Lake species in Eryn Lasgalen and the Dale-lands, including Bleak, Bream, Burbot, Chub, Gudgeon, Lamprey, Loach, Long Lake Salmon, Powan, Pumpkinseed, Roach, Ruffe, Sprat, Sunbleak, Tench and Tilapia. You must also visit Lake-town.
Other deeds
Here Fishy Fishy Fishy: find all the fish trophies in Lake-town. Fortunate Festival Fishes: catch 10 fish during the Farmers Faire festival, which also has its own seasonal fishing quests.
Fishing titles
| Title | Requirement |
|---|---|
| Apprentice Angler | Proficiency 10 |
| Journeyman Angler | Proficiency 50 |
| Expert Angler | Proficiency 100 |
| Master Angler | Proficiency 150 |
| Lord of Streams / Lady of Streams | Proficiency 200 |
| The Compleat Angler | Catch a 50-pound Salmon |
| Trout-master, Darter-master, Sturgeon-master, Lake-master | Complete the matching deed |
Fish for cooking
Fish that cooks can use have a green icon background. Several of them can be processed into Pair of Fish Fillets (Apprentice Cook): Carp, Catfish, Dace, Flounder, Golden Mullet, Largemouth Bass, Perch and Brown Trout.
| Dish | Fish | Tier | Effect / notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fried Dace with Mushrooms | Dace | Apprentice | +Will buff |
| Catfish Cakes | Catfish | Journeyman | +Will buff |
| Perch Fillet | Perch | — | +Will (Superior) |
| Golden Mullet Chowder | Golden Mullet | Expert | +Will |
| Bass with Carrots and Onions | Largemouth Bass | Expert | +Will |
| Roasted Carp | Carp | Supreme | — |
| Flounder with Bacon / Baked Flounder / Flounder Fillet | Flounder | Artisan | Power and/or Morale over time; Lossoth standing Friend / Ally / Kindred |
Buff values were rescaled in later updates, so check in game for current numbers.
Sources
- LOTRO Wiki: Fishing · Fish · Hobby Master · Hobby Titles · Fishing Deeds · Fishing Rods
- The Compleat Angler's Visual Guide to Fishing in Middle-earth (fish, junk and salmon level tables)
- The Angler's Guide to Fishing in LOTRO (original community research)
- Ten Ton Hammer: At the Fishin' Hole · Mastering Lore: Fishing hints
- Catch statistics: our own chat logs, listed in "Sessions in this study".